At the fifty-seat café, diners can sit down to a full-service lunch, ordered from the market’s menu. Converted from a former antique shop, the café has a decidedly country-casual atmosphere, adorned with local landscapes and still life paintings by regional artists and, of course, images of our hunky namesake, Robert Mitchum.

CAFÉ MENU

Print the Cafe Menu

BREAKFAST

Fresh Fruit market price
Danishes $2
Muffins $2
Croissants $2
Fresh-Brewed Coffee $.95/$1.25
Fresh-Brewed Iced Tea $.95/$1.25

LUNCH SANDWICHES

Oven-Roasted Turkey $5.50
Rare Roast Beef $5.95
Genoa Salami $5.25
Smoked Ham $5.25
Corned Beef $5.50
Tuna Salad $5.95
Shredded Chicken Salad $7.25
Spiced Jumbo Shrimp Salad $8.25

SALADS

Belmont Steak Salad $11.50
steakhouse-rubbed beef tenderloin, hearts of romaine, sweet grape tomatoes, red onion, homemade croutons, with garlic bleu cheese or creamy ranch dressing

BLT Salad with Grilled Chicken $11.25
smoked bacon, lettuce, red onions, sweet grape tomatoes, homemade croutons, with creamy ranch
or balsamic vinaigrette dressing

The Three-Scoop Salad $11.95
shrimp, chicken & tuna salads served on a bed of fresh hearts of romaine and sweet grape tomatoes

Garden Salad $3.95
tomato, red onion, homemade croutons

Key Lime Caesar with Parmesan & Homemade Croutons $5.75

Add to the Caesar & Garden Salads

Chicken Salad $5.25
Tuna Salad $4.75
Shrimp Salad $6.95
Grilled Chicken $5.25
Grilled Steak $5.95

LOCAL FAVORITES

Homemade Daily Soup Specials $3.75 / $4.75 / $5.75

Homemade Daily Seafood Soup Specials $4.75 / $5.75 / $6.75

Grilled Belmont Steak Sandwich $9.95
steakhouse-seasoned beef tenderloin, tomato, lettuce, grilled onions, provolone cheese, with creamy horseradish or Mitchum’s BBQ sauce on a fresh baguette

Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich $8.50
seasoned and sliced chicken breast, tomato, lettuce, grilled onions, with horseradish or Mitchum’s BBQ sauce on a fresh baguette

Cherry Grove Classic Club $8.75
oven-roasted turkey, smoked ham, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise on toasted white bread

Jamaica Point Pulled Pork $7.50
slow-smoked Boston Butt, hand-pulled and simmered in Mitchum’s BBQ sauce on a fresh Kaiser roll, with a side of cole slaw

Shredded BBQ Chicken $7.95
hand-pulled and simmered in Mitchum’s BBQ sauce on a fresh Kaiser roll, with a side of cole slaw

Triple Delight Mini Sandwiches $8.95
jumbo shrimp salad, chicken salad & tuna salad, lettuce, tomato on three mini rolls

Ingleside Club Sandwich $8.95
spiced jumbo shrimp salad, bacon, lettuce, tomato on a fresh croissant

Tuna Melt Wrap $7.25
white albacore tuna, melted provolone cheese, tomato, grilled in a wrap

Grilled Reuben (with Corned Beef) $7.95
Grilled Rachel (with Turkey) $7.95
corned beef or turnkey, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, Thousand Island dressing on grilled rye bread

World’s Greatest Sandwich $8.50
smoked ham, Genoa salami, Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, sweet peppers, vinaigrette on grilled Focaccia bread

Thunder Road Grinder $7.75
roast beef, melted Swiss cheese, roasted red peppers, red onion, creamy horseradish sauce on a grilled Kaiser roll

Traditional BLT $4.95

Grilled Cheese $3.25

THE OUTDOOR GRILL

Mitchum’s Steakhouse Burger $8.25
lettuce, tomato, red onion on a fresh roll

Three Mini Steakhouse Burgers $8.50
lettuce, tomato, red onion on mini rolls

“Home Run Baker” Burger $8.75
BBQ Bacon Cheddar Steakhouse Burger,
grilled onions, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato on a fresh roll

Black & Bleu Burger $8.95
Cajun-rubbed burger, bleu cheese, lettuce, tomato on a fresh roll

Island Creek Mushroom & Swiss Burger $8.95
sautéed mushrooms, onions, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato on a fresh roll

WINE & BEER

House White or Red $5/glass
White Zinfandel $5/glass
Domestic Beer $3.25
Budweiser, Yuengling, Bud Light, Miller Light, Coors Light, Samuel Adams
Imported Beer $3.95
Heineken, Corona, Amstel Light